Overnight Loss of $25 Billion: Was Li Auto Mispunished?
Li Auto, a prominent player in the electric vehicle (EV) market, has recently found itself in the eye of the storm after experiencing a dramatic drop in its stock price on the NASDAQ. On August 28, the company saw its shares plummet by more than 8% right from the start of trading, with prices continuing their downward trajectory throughout the day. By the time the market closed, Li Auto's stock had nosedived to a loss of 16.12%, resulting in a staggering $3.625 billion (over 25 billion RMB) decrease in market capitalization overnight.
The catalyst for this sudden plummet can be traced back to Li Auto's most recent financial disclosures, which, upon first glance, did not appear to paint a bleak picture. The company reported a revenue of 57.3 billion RMB for the first half of the year, marking a notable year-on-year growth of 20.81%. However, beneath this growth lay a net profit of only 1.695 billion RMB, indicating a concerning decline of 47.4% compared to last year. This drop in profitability, primarily attributed to the setbacks of the MEGA model, led to heightened expectations and jitters in the market.
Advertisement
While it's true that Li Auto stands as a remarkable contender among new automotive forces, especially when juxtaposed with its rivals, questions still loom large regarding its future trajectory. Xpeng, another rival in the EV sphere, reported half the revenue of Li’s in the same timeframe and was still grappling with substantial losses. In contrast, Li has managed to post consistent profits over several quarters and even recorded impressive sales figures, with its July sales exceeding 50,000 units, signaling solid market demand.
Nevertheless, despite these seemingly positive metrics, the market’s reaction to Li Auto’s financial report raises eyebrows. Why such a severe drop in stock price when the fundamentals didn’t seem drastically flawed? It becomes evident upon closer examination of the financial report that there are indeed underlying concerns that may have prompted the harsh capitalization adjustment.
A deeper analysis reveals the disturbing reality that Li Auto, while still reporting profits, is grappling with significant operational losses. On paper, the company reported a profit, but this masked an operational loss of 1.169 billion RMB for the same period, masked by earnings from interest and investments that covered the operational deficits. The financial reports painted an image at odds with the reality of day-to-day operations, prompting investors to ponder the sustainability of such a scenario.
Furthermore, the profit margin statistics raise pertinent questions. It was reported that Li Auto recorded a gross margin of 20.0%, down from 21.2% in 2023. This drop brings into question the company’s pricing strategies, especially as the model L6 has emerged as the primary product in terms of sales volume, overtaking other models such as L7, L9, and L8. The selling price of the L6 is notably lower, which directly dilutes the company's overall profit margin — a troubling trend for a company seeking to sustain its competitive edge.
Such operational challenges are further compounded by the intensifying competition within the EV landscape. Li Auto, which previously exhibited strict cost controls and fiscal discipline, has had to significantly increase its investment in research and marketing to keep pace with rivals like Huawei’s Aito lineup. The sharp hike in research and marketing expenses — nearly 42% and 46.47% respectively compared to the previous year — highlights the company's urgent response to competitive pressures. Despite these efforts, however, comparisons of sales figures indicate that Li Auto is losing ground, as demonstrated by stark contrasts with rival sales in similar segments, creating a sense of urgency within the company.
For Li Auto to reclaim its position and restore investor confidence, a successful pivot towards pure electric vehicles is essential. Unlike the current focus on range-extended models, which portray a challenge in the higher-end market, Li needs to hone in on the demand for pure EVs. This approach could empower the company to engage directly with consumers in this rapidly evolving market.
As more automotive firms launch their own range-extended models, often targeting Li Auto's market share, the competitive environment has become alarmingly saturated. Organizations like Leap Motor are trailblazing with low-cost alternatives, presenting an acute challenge to Li's historically secured position. Moreover, changes in government policy towards range-extended vehicles have begun shifting consumer sentiment away from such models, following stringent regulations in leading EV cities like Shanghai.
Based on the landscape, the potential for Li Auto's success in the pure electricity domain remains uncertain. Demand data indicates that consumer interest in high-end purely electric SUVs pales in comparison to that for hybrid or range-extending options. The current shoulders of the market show that plug-in hybrids significantly dominate consumer preference, and high-end pure electric options trail far behind, revealing latent challenges for Li Auto's ambitions.
The company is aware of the growing difficulties it faces in achieving success in the pure electric segment, acknowledging that plans to launch several electric models are being pushed back to 2025. This cautious approach reflects the sober realization of its competitive position, further supplemented by remarks from CEO Li Xiang expressing confidence in eventually asserting its strength in the segment.
The future of Li Auto will not only depend on market conditions but also on how effectively the company navigates the competitive and regulatory landscapes. As stock prices exhibit pessimistic sentiment from investors, the prevailing sentiment underscores an urgent need for concrete steps towards enhanced product offerings and competitiveness in the pure electric market. Only through recovery and strategic adjustments can Li Auto hope to weather the storm and regain its footing in the fast-evolving automotive industry.